Agile isn’t dead. It’s evolving through alignment.

When the hashtag #AgileIsDead began trending in early 2025, it wasn’t the methodology that failed. It was the way it was implemented. Agile itself isn’t outdated; it’s in a phase of renewal and refinement. As depicted in our diagram below, it’s a hands-on approach where projects are divided into short cycles called sprints. Teams focus on working together, getting feedback often, and making steady improvements as they go.

The real challenge isn’t Agile’s principles but how organizations take those ideas and weave them into daily routines. As technology consultants with over two decades of experience, we’ve seen Agile soar, and stall, based on one crucial element: alignment between strategy and delivery.

Why most agile transformations fall short

Numerous studies paint a harsh reality. Latest research from McKinsey & Company shows nearly three-quarters of Agile transformations fail to generate meaningful outcomes. Another source notes a startling 47% failure rate for Agile rollouts, often linked to inconsistency in practice and poor organizational support. Even more alarming is a finding that projects claiming to follow Agile Manifesto principles may be up to 268% more likely to fail, though these numbers warrant deeper scrutiny.

The root causes? They’re all-too familiar: Agile emerges from the grass roots (driven by enthusiastic teams) but lacks executive alignment. Without strong leadership, Agile principles become misinterpreted slogans or process “checklists.” Teams get bogged down in ceremonies without momentum. And before long, frustration mounts and the transformation fizzles.

The real work starts at the top

Agile, at its core, isn’t about adopting Scrum rituals or tracking velocity; it’s about cultivating a culture of responsiveness, autonomy, and shared purpose.

1. Leadership engagement: beyond the surface

In a recent analysis of 24 studies covering over 21,000 participants, researchers found that agile leadership isn’t just a nice-to-have; it truly moves the needle. The link to operational performance was notably strong (effect size 0.58), which means teams led in an agile way consistently worked better. And while the impact on employee well-being was slightly more modest (effect size 0.48), it was still meaningfully positive.

What’s most striking is that these leaders do not stand on pedestals. Instead, they build trust, spark creativity, encourage teams to work together across departments, and show an ability to adjust plans when the situation changes—not because they are told to, but because they believe it helps everyone do better.

Simply put, successful Agile leadership is about creating an environment where people feel respected, supported, and free to experiment. And that is exactly what leads to stronger outcomes for both the teams and the organization as a whole.

2. Shared language and common goals

Without a shared understanding, Agile teams speak their own dialect, leading to miscommunication, friction, and misaligned expectations. The 2023 17th State of Agile report finds 59% of practitioners cite better collaboration and 57% improved alignment with business needs when Agile is aligned with organizational strategy.

For proactive organizations, linking Agile backlogs and epics to high-level OKRs creates transparency and ensures team outputs support strategic outcomes.

3. Top-down support, not bottom-up isolation

Agile efforts often stall when leaders stay on the sidelines. Without real commitment from executives, teams remain isolated pilots with no chance to scale beyond their corners of the organization.

Leadership has to model Agile behavior: embrace shorter planning cycles, join team demos, make fast decisions, and give people room to learn from mistakes. Equally important is tearing down the walls between departments. When leaders actively build bridges instead of allowing silos, Agile stops being a pilot project and becomes a core way of working.

What agile needs to thrive

To truly move from hype to impact, Agile needs something deeper than rituals—it needs an environment that supports it.

1. Leadership that walks the talk

Set an example: leaders who practice iteration in planning, empower instead of delegate, and use real data to manage change.

2. Shared language, shared outcomes

Hold alignment workshops for executives and teams. Use unified tools. Flatten hierarchies. Provide continuous education—not just for teams, but for middle management and leadership.

3. Organizational sponsorship

From the C-suite down, Agile needs to be part of the operating model—not something teams do on the side. Structurally, this might mean adjusting budgeting, resource allocation, metrics, and talent mobility in support of Agile ways of working.

4. Empowerment at the team level

Teams must be given real decision-making power. According to Forbes, studies show micromanagement stifles innovation and delays feedback loops, ultimately killing Agile’s intrinsic advantages.

5. Realistic timelines and maturity models

Agile maturity is a journey—one that requires cycles of experimentation, review, and refinement. Don’t expect miracles in six weeks; prioritize continuous improvement, not overnight transformation.

Adapt or stagnate

Agile brought us an unprecedented boost in innovation, customer satisfaction, and organizational flexibility. But its future impact depends on two factors many practitioners miss:

1. Leadership must share accountability. Agile transformations succeed when leaders rethink strategy and execution as two sides of the same coin.
2. Culture must evolve with the method. Incentives, boundaries, budgets, and even physical workspace must support experimentation, collaboration, and transparency.

Organizations committed to these changes report measurable benefits. According to CertLibrary's 2025 State of Agile Report, Agile brings increased transparency, improved risk management, and enhanced stakeholder engagement to delivery teams. And the 17th State of Agile Report puts the success rate of Agile-run projects at 75.4%, compared to ~74% for predictive or hybrid models.

A checklist for agile revival

Use this framework to assess whether you’re truly set up for success:

Final thoughts

Agile won’t die simply because it was misapplied. Its true promise lies not in frameworks, but in mindset, and mindsets that aren’t supported by aligned leadership, organizational structure, and culture eventually give way.

For organizations ready to move forward, the most important step is linking strategy to execution. Bring leadership into planning sessions with delivery teams. Create incentives that align with strategic goals. Empower squads to make decisions independently. Cut out unnecessary red tape. Ensure leaders stay actively involved. Build mutual trust, and don’t forget to celebrate the small wins along the way. Each of these actions helps turn Agile from theory into a powerful, practical way of working.

Be sure to follow The Select Group for more real-world insights and tips for navigating modern business challenges.